Over 500 Science and History Articles Absolutely Free
We made all 5th grade reading level versions of our curriculum free and they're ready to be used in your classrooms.
Evidence for Evolution: Analogous and Homologous Structures
fossil record, homologous structure, analogous structure, vestigial structure, evolution
Evolution Unit
The evidence of evolution is deep and far-reaching. When they look at every level of how living systems are organized, biologists see the mark of past and present changes. A large part of Darwin's book, On the Origin of Species, found patterns in the world around us that make sense with evolution. Since the time of Darwin, what we know has become clearer and broader. Evolution is when living things adapt over time to their environments in ways that help them live long enough to reproduce. This causes groups of living things to change because the parents pass on what helped them live to their children.
Fossils
Fossils give strong signs that livings things from the past are not the same as those found today. This is because they show a progression of evolution. Scientists figure out the age of fossils, or remains, and sort them all over the world to decide when the life forms lived in relationship to each other. The fossil record is made up of all the fossils that have been found to tell a story of the past and show how living things have changed over millions of years.
Fossil records with a lot of detail have been found for groups of species that have changed over time, such as whales and modern horses. The record of horses in North America is quite rich. Many have transition fossils. These show anatomy that is in between earlier and later forms. The record goes back to a dog-like ancestor some 55 million years ago that gave rise to the first horse-like species 55 to 42 million years ago in the genus Eohippus. This group of remains shows the change in anatomy that came from drying over time that changed the land from a forest to a prairie. Fossils that followed show the change over time of teeth shapes and how the leg and foot are built for a habit of eating grass with changes for running from animals that may eat them. This happened with a species of Mesohippus found from 40 to 30 million years ago. More recent ones showed gains in size, such as those of Hipparion, which was around from about 23 to 2 million years ago. The record shows several changes in the horse lineage. It is now only one genus, Equus, with several species.
A set of paintings on a timeline from 55 million years ago to today showing 4 of the ancestors to the horses of the present.
The first painting is of Eohippus, which lived from 55 to 45 million years ago. It was a small animal that was the size of a dog with 4 toes on the front feet and 3 on the back, a long tail, and a brown coat with spots. The second is Mesohippus, which lived from 40 to 30 million years ago. It was a bit larger than Eohippus with longer legs. It had 3 toes on the front and back feet. The third is Hipparion, which lived from 23 to 2 million years ago. It walked on its middle toe on each foot (now a hoof), but it still had hints of the remaining toes. It was much larger than Mesohippus. The fourth is Przewalski's horse. This is a recent but endangered horse. It is smaller and stockier than the domesticated horse with one toe (hoof) on each foot.
This drawing is of species that come from the remains of the evolutionary history of the horse. The species shown are only four from a very diverse line that has many branches, dead ends, and adaptations. One of the changes shown here is from a forest to a prairie. This is shown in forms that are better for eating grasses and escaping from animals who may eat them by running. Przewalski's horse is one of a few living species of horse.
Anatomy
Another way to prove evolution is with structures in living things that share the same simple form. The bones in the limbs of a human, dog, bird, and whale all share the same overall way they are built. What is similar comes from their beginning in the appendages of a shared ancestor. Over time, evolution led to changes in the shapes and sizes of these bones in different species. They have, however, kept the same general form. This shows that they came from a shared ancestor. These similar parts are called homologous structures. Some are present in living things that have no clear function at all and appear to be remaining parts from a past ancestor. Some snakes have pelvic bones even though they do not have legs. They came from reptiles that did have legs. Vestigial structures are parts left over in animals that do not have a clear job in the body. They come from a past ancestor that did use the body part at one time, but have not been lost because they do not hurt the animal’s ability to live. These are shown with wings on birds that cannot fly (which may have other jobs) and the sightless eyes of cave animals, among others.
This drawing compares a human arm, dog and bird legs and a whale flipper. All of these limbs have the same bones, but the size and shape of these bones can be different.
These limbs are built in a similar manner. This picture shows that these living things share an ancestor.
Similarity of Form
Another sign of evolution is the coming together of form in living things that share similar living places. Species of animals that are not related, such as the arctic fox and ptarmigan (a bird), live in the Arctic and have white covers during winter to match with the snow and ice. What is similar happens not because of shared ancestors. Indeed, one cover is of fur and the other of feathers. They happened instead because of needs that are similar, such as the use of not being seen by predators.
Both the arctic fox and ptarmigan have evolved a color that helps them blend into their surroundings. They aren't related, but have evolved in a similar environment.
Two Measures of Similarity
Life forms that share similar physical features and genetic sequences are likely more closely related than those that do not. Characteristics that overlap both in form and genetically are referred to as homologous structures. The similarities stem from evolutionary paths that are similar. As shown in the next image, the bones in the wings of bats and birds, the arms of humans, and the front leg of a horse are homologous structures. Notice that the form is not simply a single bone. Rather, it is a group of several bones put together in a way that is similar in each life form even though the parts of the structure may have changed in shape and in size.
Photo A shows a bird in flight with a drawing of bird wing bones. B shows a bat in flight with a drawing of bat wing bones. C shows a horse with a drawing of front leg bones. D shows a beluga whale with a drawing of flipper bones. E shows a human arm with a drawing of arm bones.
All the limbs share common bones, which is like the bones in the arms and fingers of humans. However, in the bat wing, finger bones are long and separate and form a scaffolding on which the wing's membrane is stretched. In the bird wing, the finger bones are united together. In the horse leg, the ulna is shorter and is fused to the radius. The hand bones are reduced to one long thick bone, and the finger bones are reduced to one long thick finger with a modified nail or hoof. In the whale flipper, the humerus and other bones are very short and thick.
Bat and bird wings, the front leg of a horse, the flipper of a whale, and the arm of a human are homologous structures. This shows that bats, birds, horses, whales, and humans have a shared evolutionary past.
Misleading Appearances
Some life forms may be very closely related, even though a small genetic change caused a major morphological difference to make them look quite different. Chimpanzees and humans, the skulls of which are shown in the next image, share 99 percent of their genes. However, they show major anatomical differences, such as how much the jaw sticks out in the adult and the lengths of our arms and legs.
A chimpanzee skull and a human skull. Though we look different from the outside, we share 99% of the same genes.
However, unrelated life forms may be distantly related yet appear very much alike. This is often because common adaptations to similar conditions came about in both. This can be seen in the streamlined body shapes, the shapes of fins and appendages, and the tails in fishes and whales, which are mammals. These structures have a surface-level similarity because they are adaptations to moving about in the same living space, water. Analogous structures are different body parts in different animals that do similar jobs, like the wing of a bat and the wing of an insect. They are alike not because the animals are related, but because they evolved in a similar environment. For one, insects use wings to fly like bats and birds. We call them both wings because they have the same job and have a similar form on the surface. The embryonic origin of the two wings is quite different. The difference in the development of the wings in each case is a signal that insects and bats or birds do not share an ancestor that had a wing. The wing structures, shown in the next image, came about in each of the two lineages on their own.
The wings of a bat, bird and bee all look fairly similar, but evolved in different ways to solve the same problem: flight.
Traits, or parts passed down from parents, can be either homologous or analogous. The first kind share an evolutionary path that led to the making of that trait. Analogous traits do not share that path. Scientists must decide which kind of similarity a feature shows to figure out the group of the life forms being studied.
References